Public Statement on Prashant Bhushan's contempt case

By -


Statement to the Supreme Court and to the Public of India at large.



We, the below named, practicing members of the bar in India, have noted with dismay, the judgment of the Supreme Court, in Mr. Prashant Bhushan's contempt case. An independent judiciary consisting of independent judges and lawyers, is the basis of the rule of law in a Constitutional democracy. Mutual respect and the absence of coercion, are the hallmarks of a harmonious relationship between the bar and bench. Any tilting of the balance, one way or the other, is deleterious both to the institution and the nation.

An independent judiciary does not mean that judges are immune from scrutiny and comment. It is the duty of lawyers to freely bring any shortcomings to the notice of bar, bench and the public at large. While some of us may have divergent views on the advisability and content of Mr. Prashant Bhushan's two tweets, we are unanimously of the view that no contempt of court was intended or committed especially when contrasted with the normal standard that "Justice is not a cloistered virtue... She must be allowed to suffer the scrutiny and respectful, even though outspoken comments of ordinary men."

While Mr. Prashant Bhushan as a lawyer of good standing of the Supreme Court, may not be an ordinary man, his tweets do not say anything out of the ordinary, other than what is routinely expressed about the court's working in recent years by many on public fora and on social media. Even some retired judges of the Supreme Court have expressed somewhat similar views.

This judgment does not restore the authority of the court in the eyes of the public. Rather, it will discourage lawyers from being outspoken. From the days of the supersession of judges and the events thereafter, it has been the Bar that has been the first to stand in defence of the independence of the judiciary. A bar silenced under the threat of contempt, will undermine the independence and ultimately the strength of the Court. A silenced bar, cannot lead to a strong court.

We also express a deep sense of disappointment about the Supreme Court’s utter disregard of the presence of the Learned Attorney General, a highly respected Lawyer of great eminence, and its refusal to seek his valuable opinion in the matter, which is mandated even as per contempt law.

We are of the firm view that the judgment must not be given effect to, until a larger bench, sitting in open court after the pandemic has the opportunity to review the standards of criminal contempt. We do believe that the Supreme Court will hear the Voice of the People expressed all around in last 72 hours on the subject and take corrective steps to prevent miscarriage of Justice and restore the confidence and respect that Citizens have generally reposed in it.

Signed

1. Mr. Janak Dwarkadas
2. Mr. Navroz H Seervai
3. Mr. Darius J Khambata
4. Mr. Jayant Bhushan
5. Ms. Vrinda Grover
6. Mr. Bishwajit Bhattacharyya
7. Mr. Dushyant Dave
8. Mr. Huzefa Ahmadi
9. Mr. Arvind Datar
10. Mr. Mihir Desai
11. Mr. Anoop Feroze George Choudhary
12. Ms. June Choudhary
13. Mr. Ravindra Srivastava
14. Ms. Kamini Jaiswal
15. Mr. Prashanto Chandra Sen
16. Ms. R. Vaigai
17. Mr. Sattvik Verma
18. Mr. Amarjit Singh Chandhiok
19. Ms. Karuna Nundy
20. Mr. Sriram Panchu
21. Mr. Percy Kavina
22. Ms. Meenakshi Arora
23. Mr. Nakul Dewan
24. Mr. Ritin Rai
25. Mr. Anip Sachthey
26. Mr. Shekhar Naphade
27. Mr. Rajiv Nayyar
28. Mr. Shyam Divan
29. Mr. Lalit Bhasin
30. Mr. Pallav Shishodia
31. Mr. PP Khurana
32. Mr. Chander Uday Singh
33. Mr. Sanjay R Hegde
34. Mr. Ramji Srinivasan
35. Mr. Raju Ramachandran
36. Mr. Suhrith Parthasarathy
37. Mr. Kailash Vasdev
38. Dr. Menaka Guruswamy
39. Mr. Mustafa Doctor
40. Mr. Kirti Uppal
41. Mr. Pranjal Kishore



Next
Never submit passwords through Google Forms.
This form was created inside chamberspk.com. Report Abuse
Google Forms

Comments

Chamarthy Umamaheswara rao. said…
it is strange that some advocates of the Bar come together in support of Prashnata Bhushan's comment. If such comments go unchecked will it be far away that the country moves towards anarchy. Or do they really want such confusing situation. There are thousands of cases where civil servants are called to the court in contempt proceedings. When bar has such access to the courts at different levels ,they should air their grievances in the court and find solutions. Airing them publicly in the language of his choice whenever his argument is not accepted... this does not enhance his stature. We cannot have a situation where - there is only one way and that is my way. A goonda wants publicity of his misdeeds to create fear. He is rude in his approach . But Mr Bhushn's approach is a bit more sophisticated but objective seems to be the same-,namely cheap popularity. Let us not support this. I ,for one can not.
7:36 AM
Unknown said…
It has been a long time that Prashant Bhushan is fighting this war of suppression by this despotic BJP government under the leadership of PM Narendra Damodardas Modi who has turned the whole of India into a puppeteering stage where the puppet by the government are made to perform as per the whims and fancies of the BJP government by the master puppeteer PM Narendra Damodardas Modi, this BJP government has imposed an indirect emergency where there is no freedom of speech, people are intimidated, imprisoned without criminal charges or are just eliminated, Prashant BBhushan and those who supported him is a contribution to preserve the democracy of India and Indian's as given in the constitution of India.
2:04 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Greek, French Elections Sound Death Knell for Austerity

By -
By Julio Godoy BERLIN, May 7, 2012 (IPS) - The voting out of conservative governments in France and Greece this weekend heralds the end of harsh European austerity programmes and ushers in an era of new economic, investment, and social policies aimed at restoring growth and employment across the continent. In France, the Socialist presidential candidate François Hollande, a champion of government-led economic growth and employment strategies, accomplished a comfortable victory over the incumbent president Nicolas Sarkozy – the man often seen as the poster child of the austerity programmes in practice all over Europe. In Greece, citizens penalised the two strongest, traditional parties, New Democracy and the Pan- Hellenic Socialist Movement (PASOK), for their recent technocratic coalition government that has imposed a severe austerity plan on the country, which deepened the five-year-long recession and ignited a steep increase of unemployment and poverty Instead, Greek citizens cast the...
Read more

Home Ministry’s Population Register Worse than Prisoner Identification

By -
NPR is not Citizens Register, it’s a Register of Residents like UID/Aadhaar Privacy Bill should precede creation of NPR, RFID & Intelligence Grid Biometric data collection an act of “illegitimate advances of the (police) state” & businesses New Delhi 11/11/2011: Quite like prisoners whose biometric data like finger prints can be collected only under the Identification of Prisoners Act, 1920, it is quite outrageous that National Population Register (NPR) is taking biometric data of every resident and citizen of India disregarding absence of any legislative mandate for it. In the case of prisoners their biometric data is required to be destroyed on their acquittal but in the case of NPR and Centralized Identities Register (CIDR) of Unique Identification (UID)/Aadhaar Number, the same will be recorded for ever. Are residents and citizens worse than prisoners? In a letter to Planning Commission, Citizens Forum for Civil Liberties (CFCL) has drawn their attention towards th...
Read more

Open letter to Kim Jong-un urging a new era in North Korea

By -
Kim Jong-un Supreme Commander of the Korean People’s Army Pyongyang Democratic People’s Republic of Korea Dear Supreme Commander Kim: I am writing to recognize the passing of your father and acknowledge your leadership of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK), and to raise a number of concerns and ideas which we believe would enhance your leadership, improve the standing of your country and benefit your people. It is clear that the coming year will be one of great challenges for you and the people of North Korea. It can also be a time of great opportunity, both for your legacy and for the well-being of all the people of North Korea, provided that you seize this moment in history to ensure that your government respects the human rights and fundamental freedoms of the North Korean people. I am seriously concerned about what is happening to the people of your country. More than 200,000 men, women and children are still being held in a system of prisons and labor camp...
Read more