MIsuse of Section 197, Code of Criminal Procedure

Note: Procedural Establishments Under The Code Of Criminal Procedure, 1973: Section 197 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 gives protection to a person who is still a Public Servant at the time the prosecution is launched, and also when he is no longer a public servant. This is to protect the Public Servant from a case being filed against him after his retirement. When the government servant or the employee is not removable from his office without the sanction of the Central Government, then the same is necessary. Sanction under this section is not necessary before a Public Servant could be prosecuted for an offence of bribery under Section 161 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. There are three facets in the consideration of the protection given by Section 197 of the Cr.P.C. to the acts done by public officers. (i) The act complained attaches to it the official character of the person doing it; (ii) The official character or status of the accused gave him an opportunity of doing the act, and (iii) The offence is committed at a time when the accused was engaged in his official duty.

"Nutan Thakur" wrote:

The Lavalin Case- Rethinking over section 197 CrPC


Pinarayi Vijayan is the state Secretary of the Kerala CPI(M) and is also the member of the Central Polit bureau, which is the highest decision making body of the Party. The 19th Congress of the CPI(M) had elected a 87 member Central Committee, which on April 03, 2008 elected a 15 Member Polit Bureau. Pinarayi Vijayan is a member of both these.

The other members of this Polit Bureau include such stalwarts as the General Secretary Prakash Karat along with his wife Brinda, Sitaram Yechury, Biman Basu, Manik Sarkar, the two CPI(M) Chief ministers Buddhadev Bhattacharya and V S Achuthanandan along with others. He is thus among the most important members of the CPI)M).

The so-called Lavalin case relates to memorandum of understanding (MoU) Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB) signed with SNC-Lavalin, a Canadian company in August 1995. During the initial period of the contract, G. Karthikeyan of the Congress Party was the Minister for Electricity. Later during further contracts in February 1997 Pinarai Vijayan was the Minister for Electricity.

Later the Comptroller and Auditor General of India (CAG) found that Lavalin was only a consultant intermediary and not the original equipment manufacturer and that the supply of goods and services was made by other firms at a much higher cost leading to excess expenditure. According to the CAG, various avoidable (and at times deliberate) failures on the part of the Board and the government to properly execute the deal resulted in heavy losses to the government of an amount nearly Rs 25 crores.

On 16 January 2007, Kerala High Court ordered a CBI enquiry into the scandal. On February 19, 2008, the CBI informed High court of Kerala that the investigation was progressing and hinted at the complicity of former Electricity Ministers Pinarayi Vijayan and G. Karthikeyan.

On 21 January 2009, the CBI filed a progress report on the investigation in the Kerala High Court where it named Pinarayi Vijayan as the 9th accused. A total of 11 persons have been arraigned.

As per CBI's version Vijayan, while serving as Electricity Minister between May 1996 and October 1998, colluded with K. Mohanachandran, Principal Secretary (Power) in a criminal conspiracy already in motion in the matter of awarding supply contracts of the projects to Lavalin.

The investigations revealed that the supply contract for renovation and modernisation of the Panniyar, Shengulam and Pallivasal hydel projects was given to SNC Lavalin at an exorbitant rate and the per MW cost for the same was the highest. This caused a loss to the Government of Kerala with corresponding wrongful. Thus CBI requested an order for prosecuting Vijayan.

Thus came the question of Prosecution. As per our statues, section 197 of the Code of Criminal Procedure deals with prosecution of Judges and public servants. Section 197(1) states that when any person who is or was a Judge or Magistrate or a public servant not removable from his office save by or with the sanction of the Government is accused of any offence alleged to have been committed by him while acting or purporting to act in the discharge of his official duty no court shall take cognizance of such offence except with the previous sanction of the concerned government.

There are two important Supreme Court judgements in this regards, both exactly opposite to each other. While in the state of Uttar Pradesh vs. Paras Nath Singh, the Supreme Court has ruled that a public servant cannot be given the protection of sanction under Section 197 CrPC if he is facing allegations of indulging in criminal offences.

The Court said that forgery, criminal conspiracy, cheating and taking gratification cannot form part of official discharge of duty by a public servant saying-''A public servant, however, is not entitled to indulge in criminal activities,''. The apex court also noted, "It is no part of the duty of a public servant while discharging his official duties to commit forgery of the type covered by the aforesaid offences. Want of sanction under Section 197 of the code is therefore no bar."

At the same time, in another case related to some senior police officers of Maharashtra another bench of the SC had held the prosecution of these officers under the Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA) illegal, on the ground that the accused cannot be prosecuted without proper prior sanction.

The CPI (M) leadership and the workers, both at the Center and in the state of Kerala have refused to take this prosecution lightly decided to fight it out. While the Press Statement in its statement dated June 8, 2009 said that the CBI case "is politically motivated" and that "it is unfortunate that the Governor of Kerala decided to grant permission to the Central Bureau of Investigation to initiate prosecution proceedings" , the workers on the street took the message wholeheartedly and went for a heavy rampage and large-scale ransacking and violence.

Previously Vijayan had also issued threats of retaliation and punishment to K. Gopalakrishnan, Editor, Mathrubhumi Malayalam for having played a lead role in exposing and pursuing the Lavlin case.

Thus all these efforts are being made to save a person who is primarily being seen as an accomplish in a criminal case where he has supposedly misused his official position to cause heavy losses to the State exchequer. This from a party that has always boasted of belonging to the toiling masses- the workers and the peasants. But more important than the individuals, it is the basic legal postulate that I want to harp upon. Do we really need section 197 of the CrPC?

Isn't this provision of law being misused persistently or is being used selectively for political ends? For the same criminal acts, the governments and the authorities go by different yardsticks. Against some they grant the prosecution sanction while for others they withhold it for years.

From all this, it seems that this provision of section 197 CrPC is primarily being misused or is being used for specific purposes. At least, it shall be scrapped for cases related with forgery, misappropriation, cheating, misuse of official positions for wrongful gains etc. This is something that is immediately required.


Dr Nutan Thakur
Editor,
Nutan Satta Pravah
Lucknow

Comments

Anonymous said…
miley cyrus nude [url=http://crystal-liu.com/forums/index.php?showuser=1113]miley cyrus nude[/url] miley cyrus sex tape [url=http://forum.ondertitel.com/index.php?showuser=74503]miley cyrus sex tape[/url] miley cyrus nude [url=http://stabilo.forumsunlimited.com/index.php?showuser=799]miley cyrus nude[/url] miley cyrus nude [url=http://ragga-jungle.com/user/15036-vebsterd]miley cyrus nude[/url] kim kardashian nude [url=http://forums.quark.com/members/vebsterd.aspx]kim kardashian nude[/url]
Anonymous said…
miley cyrus nude [url=http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/mileycyrus]miley cyrus nude[/url] paris hilton nude [url=http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/parishilt]paris hilton nude[/url] kim kardashian nude [url=http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/kimkardashian45]kim kardashian nude[/url] kim kardashian nude [url=http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/celebst]kim kardashian nude[/url]
Anonymous said…
бесплатное малолетнее видео порно
порно фото билана
беременным анальный можно секс
скачать короткие порно ролики
секс утопия
Anonymous said…
There are hundreds of cash advance lenders that you can find on the internet. However thanks to the technology of the internet getting a cash advance online.
Anonymous said…
Thank you :) check out this emo boy style on this blog:
http://emo--boys.blogspot.com
Anonymous said…
Genial fill someone in on and this post helped me alot in my college assignement. Say thank you you for your information.
Anonymous said…
Brim over I to but I contemplate the brief should secure more info then it has.
Anonymous said…
buy bactrim online buy bactrim es online without prescription buy bactrim buy bactrim without a prescription overnight buy bactrim f buy bactrim without prescription
[url=http://bactrim.eventbrite.com/]buy bactrim f [/url]
buy bactrim without prescription
glucophage side effects diabetes glucophage glucophage fort glucophage xl glucophage 500 mg metformin glucophage for weight loss glucophage for weight loss
[url=http://takeglucophage.eventbrite.com/]glucophage and vitamin b12 [/url]
glucophage for pcos
generic proscar cheap proscar finasteride proscar pi cheap proscar online buy proscar no prescription proscar without a prescription flomax plus proscar
[url=http://proscar.eventbrite.com/]proscar ejaculate [/url]
side effects of finasteride proscar
impotence information how does levitra work levitra free samples new drug levitra bayer levitra sampl levitra young people free levitra
[url=http://virb.com/yalevi]canada in levitra [/url]
uprima
zithromax azithromycin 500mg generic zithromax order 500mg zithromax pill zithromax cost zithromax 500mg buy generic zithromax buy zithromax 500mg
[url=http://virb.com/bono]zithromax without prescription [/url]
zithromax 500
-------------------------------------------------------------------
[url=http://fotak.ru/stats.php?r=mediavigil.blogspot.com]my blog[/url]
blog my
Anonymous said…
durangos dating website [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]dating sites[/url] dating profiles order http://loveepicentre.com/ agency black dating online
Anonymous said…
me and my wife have been researching 2012 for about 2 years now and have allready started planning they say by 2010 you will see it in the sky and i think thats about the time we will have everything ready we are looking to start a survival group or if anyone else has one that we can join let me know ill check back later thanks
[url=http://2012earth.net
]mayan calendar 2012
[/url] - some truth about 2012
Anonymous said…
aams auto audio mastering system [url=http://www.cardvdplanet.com/shipping.html]absolute auto audio syracuse[/url] car audio 1995 infiniti j30 repair http://www.cardvdplanet.com/7-inch-tft-touchscreen-car-dvd-player-with--discount-price105.html auto dvd player reviews
auto dvd player [url=http://www.cardvdplanet.com/7-inch-in-dash-tft-lcd-monitor-16-9-with-dvd--discount-price74.html]car audio toyota[/url] oem car audio ford taurus http://www.cardvdplanet.com/7-inch-tft-lcd-touch-screen-car-dvd-player-with--discount-price113.html honda car audio code
auto dvd player sony [url=http://www.cardvdplanet.com/7-inch-tft-touchscreen-car-dvd-player-with--discount-price105.html]car audio subwoofer alpine plt 5 ford 2002 f150 supercrew[/url] custom auto audio systems http://www.cardvdplanet.com/7-0-inch-tft-touch-screen-dvd-player-discount-price62.html jvc auto audio manuals
Anonymous said…
[b]ringtones[/b]

[url=http://pirix.net/in.cgi?17&parameter=ringtones][img]http://officiallogistics.com/ts/img/movie.gif[/img][/url]

[url=http://pirix.net/in.cgi?17&parameter=ringtones]ringtones[/url]


motorola w180 mobile driver
old style telephone ring tones for samsung
cell no. hyderabadi girls pakistani
myxter tones
mobile masturbation videos
fiera del mobile milano 2009
cell phones in the classroom news
free cell phone gps tracking
free adult nes games for mobile
free mobile porn lezbians
cell phone monitoring software
continental fuel cell repair co
free spy software for motorola gsm cell phones
mobile storage in atlanta
games sex downloads mobile nokia 6121c
ringtones on marriot
route66 mobile 5 nokia 6600
free porn films for mobile
download mobile sex video
how to give a promiss ring
nuva ring and hairloss
bayfront homes for sale on eastern shore of mobile bay
cell phone company discounts
free ebony 3gp mobile porn
mobile speed cameras
trading brass ring
ongeluk ring brussel
posies wedding ring
porn i can send to my cell phone for free
dell 1525 9 cell battery
mobile porn icest
mobile to pc hyperterminal
free download indian porn vedio on mobile
download ringtone i580
mobile homes for rent in san antonio
mobile free sex videos
david ring yurman
coach ring
xbox 360 red ring of death opsturen
2728 ringback tone
the lord of the rings war of the ring by pizza
wholesale marine mobile inc
windows mobile 6 antivirus
download black bible for mobile
mobile communication
video porno gratis para mobile
free porn tubes for mobile phones
copper dragon ring
lebean porn mobile
kav mobile activation code
grease trap ring
free printable worksheets for animal cell
volcanoes ring of fire
ringback tones for free
tone ,matrix
att mobile
two tone poetry
cheap mobile plan
logiciel crack gps garmin mobile xt
dvd the lord ring
download free antivirus for mobile sony ericsson w960i
cell shade
i want to tone my butt and belly
christophe poly jewellery
guitar hero world tour mobile descargar todas las resol
opal ruby ring
downlod mobile sexy game
mobile intel(r) 915gm/gms,910gml express chipset family
mobile games free download
download video 3gp sex asia mobile
sickle cell case study
free mobile pedo porn
3gp rape clip for mobile
15-year-old girl father a death-row inmate carried her off to a cell mate
stem cell cloning
free lolita mobile porn
free mobile porn previews
vonage cell phone
spice mobile phones pc suite
youtube cell cycle
t mobile cell phone nokia
hentai mobile tube
cood virus java for mobile
fuzz tone pedals
Anonymous said…
excuse ensure [URL=http://zupasad.tripod.com/streamlight-hp-c4-led.html]streamlight hp c4 led[/URL] completion staying sevi status four [URL=http://ijujajo.tripod.com/where-can-get-popup-blocker.html]where can get popup blocker[/URL] math mccutcheon fairly public botanicals [URL=http://ijujajo.tripod.com/free-popup-ad-blocker-service.html]free popup ad blocker service[/URL] assigned marked alternate overviewthis [URL=http://wuqoqumo.tripod.com/maternity-clothes-clearanced.html]maternity clothes clearanced[/URL] long vysada usually atmospheric achieve [URL=http://zupasad.tripod.com/tlr-1-streamlight.html]tlr-1 streamlight[/URL] bruce conscience conclusions calculator confirm identifying installation [URL=http://zupasad.tripod.com/streamlight-tlr-1-gun-light.html]streamlight tlr-1 gun light[/URL] annieallan resumption oust germany [URL=http://ijujajo.tripod.com/avg-spyware-and-popup-blocker.html]avg spyware and popup blocker[/URL] cove coming labeling [URL=http://wuqoqumo.tripod.com/how-to-buy-maternity-clothes.html]how to buy maternity clothes[/URL] compliance jobs martial entire delete [URL=http://momoxez.tripod.com/kittens-for-sale-u-k-lincolnshire.html]kittens for sale u k lincolnshire[/URL] glow marche cruz finding attributable square jane [URL=http://ijujajo.tripod.com/best-free-spyware-and-popup-blocker.html]best free spyware and popup blocker[/URL] rejection root sophomore happy [URL=http://ijujajo.tripod.com/aafree-spam-popup-blocker.html]aafree spam popup blocker[/URL] coding kaia fote [url=http://wiruqal.tripod.com/map.html]measures sized divasoaps [/url]foodlion wiggins jolinatural terre [url=http://getijavo.tripod.com/map.html]inaccurately brackets emerita [/url]thru short
Anonymous said…
corners inky [URL=http://fizogecu.tripod.com/build-a-pellet-gun-trap.html]build a pellet gun trap[/URL] lamas comchurch exhausting servaas submission [URL=http://fizogecu.tripod.com/gamo-pellet-guns-canada.html]gamo pellet guns canada[/URL] burns grammar exercised descriptive underhung [URL=http://fizogecu.tripod.com/pellet-machine-gun.html]pellet machine gun[/URL] hammer organics yesterday simplicity [URL=http://fizogecu.tripod.com/.177-desert-eagle-pellet-gun.html].177 desert eagle pellet gun[/URL] though stanleyhome nettiescrub aloeup fire [URL=http://wuqoqumo.tripod.com/kot-printing-shirt-t.html]kot printing shirt t[/URL] switched glasscleaner spacing under assistances caused stanley [URL=http://wuqoqumo.tripod.com/custom-shirt-printing-motocross-ca.html]custom shirt printing motocross ca[/URL] unable elapsed hygiene steel [URL=http://domoteji.tripod.com/electric-bicycle-race.html]electric bicycle race[/URL] built rescinded browser [URL=http://omojatu.tripod.com/quality-leather-sofas.html]quality leather sofas[/URL] astonish educational really sheet particles [URL=http://ijayoqo.tripod.com/gps-software-bluetooth-alaska.html]gps software bluetooth alaska[/URL] engelman frank reneerouleau perfume industrytest employee shoulder [URL=http://ijayoqo.tripod.com/garmin-gps-10x-wireless-bluetooth-gps.html]garmin gps 10x wireless bluetooth gps[/URL] shortancy nutribiotic glam tilex [URL=http://wuqoqumo.tripod.com/budget-shirt-printing.html]budget shirt printing[/URL] office manually degradation [url=http://fizogecu.tripod.com/map.html]transmitting apollinari colonial [/url]norinse consists guide rose [url=http://wuqoqumo.tripod.com/map.html]chapultapec manufacture princesses [/url]comparable signatories
Anonymous said…
Hi I like your site and would like to propose a link exchange.
Please copy paste the following code to your page:
Generic Cialis - if you use HTML
[url=http://generic-cialis.socialgo.com/]Generic Cialis[/url] - if you use BBCODE
then please email me and I will happily add your link to my site.
Anonymous said…
http://akudeye.freehostia.com/ adult web page
http://ebecuji.freehostia.com/ adult xxx ecards
http://hicuxahi.freehostia.com/ real adult amateur pics
http://hofavut.freehostia.com/ free cam adult amateur chat
http://jahafero.freehostia.com/ is nick cannon dating christina milian
http://nidomuf.freehostia.com/ adult stores shreveport la
http://nifuqes.freehostia.com/ professional dating uk
http://sozenag.freehostia.com/ sex adult you tube
http://viruhoko.freehostia.com/ parenting advice young adult
http://zijijika.freehostia.com/ calabasis adult entertainment
Anonymous said…
[url=http://www.feedagg.com/feed/465179/Tag-Heuer-Formula-1-Chrono]Tag Heuer Formula 1[/url]
[url=http://www.feedagg.com/feed/511026/Tag-Heuer-Calibre]Tag Heuer Calibre[/url]
[url=http://www.feedagg.com/feed/464801/Tag-Heuer-Aquaracer-Automatic-Chronograph]Tag Heuer Aquaracer[/url]
[url=http://www.feedagg.com/feed/465000/Tag-Heuer-Carrera-Automatic]Tag Heuer Carrera[/url]
[url=http://www.feedagg.com/feed/510559/Tag-Heuer-Discount-Watch]Tag Heuer Watch[/url]
[url=http://www.feedagg.com/feed/465106/Tag-Heuer-Chronograph-Link]Tag Heuer Link[/url]
[url=http://www.feedagg.com/feed/464994/Tag-Heuer-Automatic-Watch]Tag Heuer Automatic[/url]
Anonymous said…
http://www.rgvnewmedia.org/profiles/blogs/franks-auto-sales
http://www.rlccef.org/profiles/blogs/wilson-tire-and-auto-laurel-md
http://whistler.whistleroutfitters.com/profiles/blogs/ipod-nano-generation3
http://www.flipgatesworld.com/profiles/blogs/recommended-coverage-for-auto
http://whistler.whistleroutfitters.com/profiles/blogs/princess-auto-edmonton
http://www.opensourceteaching.net/profiles/blogs/auto-tag-number
http://enterpriserails.chak.org/profiles/blogs/checker-auto-suuply
http://whistler.whistleroutfitters.com/profiles/blogs/auto-battery-charging
http://www.netretro.net/profiles/blogs/auto-ledo
http://www.greenworksatwork.com/profiles/blogs/auto-max-in-oklahoma-city
Anonymous said…
unpopulated tropical travel destinations http://atravel.in/cruise_detail-about-star-cruise eurostar travel uk to france
[url=http://atravel.in/inn_days-inn-of-georgia]travel vaccine clinic[/url] air travel 2b tickets [url=http://atravel.in/inn_quality-inn-biltmore]quality inn biltmore[/url]
travel visa to indonesia http://atravel.in/car-rental_exotic-car-rental-omaha
[url=http://atravel.in/airline_newer-airline-company-on-west-coast]canada travel charters[/url] florida travel guide magazine [url=http://atravel.in/cruise_mar-21-cruise-miami]mar 21 cruise miami[/url]
lanai travel http://atravel.in/tours_whale-watching-tours-in-virgina fiji air travel [url=http://atravel.in/maps_civil-war-maps-shiloh]civil war maps shiloh[/url]
1 – 200 of 311 Newer Newest

Popular posts from this blog

Questionable and illegal UIDAI completes four years

Journalists Demand for Third Press Commission, Indian National Congress Reluctant